Resistors, battery, and power dissipated!!

Quiz:
There is a circuit with a battery and a resistor, R. The original voltage of the battery is V and it’s connected to an internal resistor, r.

If you want to maximize the power consumed in the resistor R, what should you do?

1. Use a larger resistance of R.
2. Use a smaller resistance of R.
3. Make R equal to r.

Answer:
The power dissipated in the external resistor is given by \(P = I^2 R\) in accordance with Ohm’s law.

The equivalent resistance of the circuit is \(R+r\) because of series connections. The current is calculated as \(I = V/R = \frac{V}{R+r}\).

Therefore, \(P = \frac{V^2 R}{(R+r)^2}\)      — (1)

You can see when \(R \rightarrow 0\), the power will be zero; and when \(R \rightarrow \infty\), the power will also be zero.

So the choices of 1 and  2 above are not the right ones. The answer must be 3, but how do you prove it?

Let’s use a trick. That is \((R+r)^2 – (R-r)^2 = 4Rr\). So we can have
\((R+r)^2 = 4Rr + (R-r)^2 \) to plug in (1). The, just keep on calculating until you get something meaningful.

\(P = \frac{V^2 R}{4Rr + (R-r)^2} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 R}{4r\left(R + \frac{(R-r)^2}{4r}\right)} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 }{4r}\frac{R}{R + \frac{(R-r)^2}{4r}} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 }{4r}\frac{1}{1 + \frac{(R-r)^2}{4Rr}} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 }{4r}\frac{1}{1 + \frac{(R-r)^2}{(R+r)^2 – (R-r)^2}} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 }{4r}\frac{1}{\frac{(R+r)^2-(R-r)^2+(R-r)^2}{(R+r)^2 – (R-r)^2}} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 }{4r}\frac{(R+r)^2 – (R-r)^2}{(R+r)^2} \) \(   = \frac{V^2 }{4r}\left\{ 1-\frac{(R-r)^2}{(R+r)^2}\right\} \)

Now, you can notice when \(R = r\), you will get the maximum power, \(\frac{V^2 }{4r}\)